[Sahana_proj] SRS Assignment grading

[Ralph Morelli]

Hi everyone,

Thanks to Gabe for taking the initiative on putting up the grading  
tables for the
various requirements documents.  However, as  I think more about  
this, I find
I'm having some reservations about it.

I'm thinking that it would be better if we could make the grading  
anonymous, for
several reasons.  For those who are taking the course for a grade, it  
would be
necessary to maintain privacy requirements, as faculty are required  
to do.  Secondly,
I think we would get a more honest assessment if students could  
submit their
evaluations of others' work anonymously. Third, our Wiki is a public  
site and
while we want to make our work visible to the public, this is one  
area (grades)
that I think we should treat in the traditional way.

So,  rather than fill out the tables on the Wiki, I would like each  
student to send me
at my private email address ralph.morelli at trincoll.edu,  your  
evaluation of each
of the other's requirements documents.    Use the following  format  
and please
put all of your evaluations into a single email message.
I will compile the scores, throw out the high and low, and compute  
the averages.

Email subject heading:  Sahana Evaluation form
Message body:

Your name:

Grades:  Writing (10), Grammar(10), Presentation(10), Introduction 
(10), Description(10), Specific Requirements (50)

Name of group you are evaluating:  e.g., Morelli and Ellis
Grades:   8, 8, 9, 10, 9, 45 = 89

We'll give this a try for this round and then evaluate.

Thanks again to Gabe. And sorry for the change.  Let's make this due  
on Friday.

Regards,
-- ram

On Oct 31, 2006, at 9:43 AM, Gabriel Fishman wrote:

> I've created a table on the wiki for users to post their grades for  
> each SRS document. Here are the instructions:
>
> 1. Go to the Requirements Documents Page on the wiki - http:// 
> www.cs.trincoll.edu/sahana_proj/wiki/Requirements_Documents
>
> 2. Find the group you want and click the blue link in the section  
> heading for that group. This will take you to a page for that group  
> - each group can use this page for anything they want, the  
> requirements document is just a start.
>
> 3. Click the edit tab at the top of the page and log in if you  
> haven't already done so.
>
> 4. In the text box, locate the line containing your name. Note how  
> many lines down from the start of the row it is (the start of the  
> row is designated by |-) - mine is the 9th column for example
>
> 5. For each row find the cell that is in your column and replace  
> the text "score" with your grade for that criterion. The grade will  
> be a fraction of the weight (e.g. 8/10 or 10/10 for Writing clear...)
>
> 6. Total up your score and insert it at the bottom of the table in  
> the cell marked (Your name) total:
>
> 7. Leave a brief note in the summary box (e.g. "grade")
>
> 8. Click save page
>
> ~Gabriel
>
> P.S. - here is the wikimarkup code for the table in case anyone  
> needs it.
>
> {|class = wikitable | border="1"
> !colspan = 13|Assignment Grading Table
> |-
> ! Criterion
> ! Weight
> ! Antonio
> ! Jonathan
> ! Dr. Ellis
> ! Turner
> ! Dr. Morelli
> ! Jas
> ! Gabriel
> ! Alicia
> ! Bach
> ! Alex
> ! Candyce
> |-
> | Submitted on time. (penalty only)
> | align = center | N/A
> | align = center | Score
> | align = center | Score
> | align = center | Score
> | align = center | Score
> | align = center | Score
> | align = center | Score
> | align = center | Score
> | align = center | Score
> | align = center | Score
> | align = center | Score
> | align = center | Score
> |-
> | Writing clear, understandable, and to the point.
> | align = center | 10
> | align = center | Score
> | align = center | Score
> | align = center | Score
> | align = center | Score
> | align = center | Score
> | align = center | Score
> | align = center | Score
> | align = center | Score
> | align = center | Score
> | align = center | Score
> | align = center | Score
> |-
> | Correct spelling, grammar, punctuation.
> | align = center | 10
> | align = center | Score
> | align = center | Score
> | align = center | Score
> | align = center | Score
> | align = center | Score
> | align = center | Score
> | align = center | Score
> | align = center | Score
> | align = center | Score
> | align = center | Score
> | align = center | Score
> |-
> | Clean and neat layout and presentation.
> | align = center | 10
> | align = center | Score
> | align = center | Score
> | align = center | Score
> | align = center | Score
> | align = center | Score
> | align = center | Score
> | align = center | Score
> | align = center | Score
> | align = center | Score
> | align = center | Score
> | align = center | Score
> |-
> | Quality of Content: Introduction
> | align = center | 10
> | align = center | Score
> | align = center | Score
> | align = center | Score
> | align = center | Score
> | align = center | Score
> | align = center | Score
> | align = center | Score
> | align = center | Score
> | align = center | Score
> | align = center | Score
> | align = center | Score
> |-
> | Quality of Content: Overall Description
> | align = center | 10
> | align = center | Score
> | align = center | Score
> | align = center | Score
> | align = center | Score
> | align = center | Score
> | align = center | Score
> | align = center | Score
> | align = center | Score
> | align = center | Score
> | align = center | Score
> | align = center | Score
> |-
> | Quality of Content: Specific Requirements
> | align = center | 50
> | align = center | Score
> | align = center | Score
> | align = center | Score
> | align = center | Score
> | align = center | Score
> | align = center | Score
> | align = center | Score
> | align = center | Score
> | align = center | Score
> | align = center | Score
> | align = center | Score
> |-
> ! Total
> ! 100
> ! Antonio Total
> ! Jonathan Total
> ! Dr. Ellis Total
> ! Turner Total
> ! Dr. Morelli Total
> ! Jas Total
> ! Gabriel Total
> ! Alicia Total
> ! Bach Total
> ! Alex Total
> ! Candyce Total
> |-
> ! colspan = 13 | Final Grade:
> |}
> _______________________________________________
> Sahana_proj mailing list
> Sahana_proj at lists.trincoll.edu
> http://lists.trincoll.edu/cgi-bin/mailman/listinfo/sahana_proj

-- ralph



-------------- next part --------------
An HTML attachment was scrubbed...
URL: http://lists.trincoll.edu/pipermail/sahana_proj/attachments/20061101/b3247a93/attachment.html